Book Direct for Best Rates!
Sunset over beach with grasses on Amelia Island
Stay Better Vacations

Welcome to Your Gateway to Amelia Island & St. Marys, Georgia

At Stay Better Vacations, we take pride in offering an array of Amelia Island vacation rentals for your unforgettable getaway on Amelia Island and in the charming locale of St. Marys, Georgia. Whether you’re seeking a serene beachfront escape or a historical adventure, or even a pet-friendly rental, we’ve got you covered. Amelia Island, Florida, and St. Marys, Georgia are waiting to be explored, and Stay Better Vacations is your trusted partner for an exceptional escape. Start your journey with us today.

Beachfront vacation rental condos at Amelia Surf and Racquet Club
Amelia Island vacation rental beach walk
Group of friends walking on the beach on Amelia Island
View of marsh from St Marys GA vacation rental house
Couple running on beach on dog friendly getaway on Amelia Island
Living room in St Marys vacation rental house
Exterior of vacation rental house in St Marys Georgia

Find Your Rental

Use the arrows below to scroll through our vacation rental categories, where you can see options pre-filtered by location or special amenity!

Stay on the Beach

Stay steps from the sand with with easy access to the water.

Walk to the Beach

Stay within a short walk to the water for some fun in the sun.

Stay in St. Marys

Relax on the river and savor the small town charm of St. Marys, Georgia.

Bring Your Dog

Bring your four-legged friend to these pet friendly units on Amelia Island.

Stay Longer

Stay for 30 days or more, whether for business or pleasure!

Get a Whole House

Look at our vacation homes with everything you need for a private, home-like feel.

1 / 7
Family having bbq at vacation rental on Amelia Island
Suit Your Style

Discover a Better Way to Stay

Planning your next vacation or business trip to Amelia Island, Florida or St. Marys, Georgia? Our professionally managed vacation rentals offer ‘better’ options for your trip! Enjoy clean and comfortable accommodations with up to four bedrooms and unique amenities like accessible features and boat parking!

  • Book direct to save on service fees!
  • Enjoy privacy, more space & full kitchens
  • Get exceptional service from the local pros
Area Attractions
Path to Amelia Island beach at sunset

There’s Something for Everyone to Enjoy

Within minutes of your Amelia Island vacation rental, you’ll find everything you need for an ideal getaway including beaches, fishing, golf, fresh seafood, biking, kayaking and so much more!

See What Makes Us Extra Special

Check out the unique services and savings we offer to make your experience exceptional!

Exclusive Offers, Savings & Services

See how you can make your experience more special or save on your stay!

Seven Night Special

Book 7 nights or more in the same unit and save 10% off the nightly rate.

Local Discounts

Save on equipment rentals and local activities during your stay.

Grocery Stocking

We’ll do your shopping and stock your rental so it’s ready the moment you arrive!

1 / 4
See What Our Guests Say

“Our host was extremely friendly, fast in replying, very flexible and kind. The view from the apartment is spectacular, fantastic sunrises and sunsets, and so close to the beach, really just few steps away!”

Benedetta P | Ketch Courtyard 104

“Nicely updated and clean. Walkable to the beach and short drive from historic downtown.”

Kevin K | Forest Ridge 2883

“We had a great stay at the well-equipped and comfortable (great beds) condo that was perfectly located for our explorations of Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island and the Talbot Islands.”

Louise V | Amelia Landings 2C

Looking to Go Beyond a Booking?

See more ways we can help with all your vacation rental needs.

Property Management

Locally owned and operated, we specialize in offering boutique-style service to both our guests and owners. Our professional service, years of experience, and local relationships will benefit you!

FAQs & Important Details

Our mission is to make your Stay Better experience as enjoyable and easy as possible. We hope that the information on our website is helpful, but if you have any questions before, during, or after your stay, we’re here for you.